Sunday Times, March 1st , 2026
Relief and then exasperation, those were the two big sighs in racing this week. Relief that Constitution Hill will not risk breaking his neck in the Champion Hurdle. Exasperation that Lord Allen looks to be yet another BHA chairman to find the sport quite literally ungovernable.
The Constitution Hill that beat Jonbon 20 lengths in the Supreme Novices Hurdle in 2022 and State Man by almost 10 in the following year’s Champion Hurdle was the most brilliant hurdler I have ever seen. And, heaven help me, I go back to watching Sir Ken on TV in 1952 and have seen every champion in the flesh since Anzio in 1962.
But Constitution Hill was not that horse anymore. He had become a brilliant athlete with a jumping flaw. Since he blundered but stood up at the final flight in Cheltenham’s Unibet Hurdle, he has run four times over hurdles and the only time he stood up was an unhappy day at Punchestown last spring when he backed off the start, show-jumped the first, and finally trailed in a demoralised fifth of six, almost 30 lengths off State Man.
The last fall, at Newcastle in November, was the least forgivable. Coasting in front at only the second hurdle, he dived at it and took the sort of somersaulting fall that can be fatal. As with the others I was out on the course and had those desperate heart-stopping moments when you are not sure if the horse is still down and then, if it’s up, whether it is galloping damage-free. I remember huge relief as Constitution Hill got up, a rueful smile as he soared riderless over the hurdle in front of us, but also the strongest of convictions that no amount of reports of schooling success would convince me that on the track Constitution Hill was any longer a safe conveyance either to himself or, lest we forget, to his rider Nico de Boinville.
Then last Friday brought the solution. At a raucous student night at Southwell, Constitution Hill reverted to the flat and so comprehensively trounced a dozen admittedly moderate opponents over a mile and a half that a whole new career opens up. His likely next aim is the John Porter Stakes at Newbury in April and his ever bold, ever worrying owner Michael Buckley is now talking of the Melbourne Cup while some, like me, feel his action on Southwell’s artificial surface gives him a chance to emulate the international heroics of Buckley’s Breeders’ Cup second Toast Of New York.
Suffice to say that no amount of good reports of his final schooling session, although some recollections do vary, could avoid the brutal truth that the risk was not worth any possible reward. I believe Constitution Hill would have cruised the Champion Hurdle if he had stood up. But that “IF” had become a huge one. Positions would have become polarised. Protesters could have been everywhere. It was everything Cheltenham did not need. Another fall would be a catastrophe. “I would have packed up,” said trainer Nicky Henderson. “It would have been the end of me if he got hurt, without a doubt.”
So from relief to exasperation. In November 2024, the British Horseracing Authority announced with understandable fanfare that Lord Charles Allen, CBE would take up the post the following June. He was clearly a big hitter. He was chairman, amongst other things, of the building giant Balfour Beatty as well as of the Invictus Games. He had been chief executive of ITV, had been knighted for his work on the London Olympics, he was a Labour peer. What could possibly go wrong?
Well, in almost trite summary, he is yet another in a long row of often almost as distinguished BHA chairman who find that the letter “A” would better stand for “Association” than “Authority”. Charles Allen clearly suspected this and delayed taking up his appointment until he had agreement of an independent board beneath him. But he also seems to have miscalculated that the Racecourse Association would allow the BHA to monetise part of their media rights as the Thoroughbred Group (owners, trainers, breeders and other participants ) would like them to do. The impasse has become complete and this week it is understood that steps are being taken to ensure an imminent and elegant exit.
The facts once again suggest that British racing’s governance is set up to fail. The above factions, and indeed different racecourse groups, have competing business objectives as indeed do bookmakers whose profits and activity are as central to the game as the equine athletics itself. The one objective they share is that racing should have a viable long-term future. They know this will need change. There are some good visions out there usually involving some sort of “Premiership” and divisional grouping first mooted a full 30 years ago. But how to get from vision to implementation?
Talk to individual leaders and everything is possible – provided someone else makes concessions. The way this happens is that we somehow find an even more high powered and charismatic figure to charm and cajole everyone on the path to righteousness. There are some very good people in there. They are friends of mine. But too soon they revert to calling opposite numbers or incoming leaders dunderheads. Unless this changes we are all on that famous primrose path to the everlasting bonfire.
Cheltenham will have its glories and excitements and disasters. But follow it with reality, goodwill and pragmatism or there will be a lot worse sighs to come.