WEIGHT FOR AGE – Brough Scott

Are John Gosden and the rest of us as ready for radical change as we say we are? If so are we prepared to change the sporting nonsense that is the weight-for-age allowance in championship races like The Eclipse, The King George, The Irish Champion and The Arc? If not, why not?
In his typically eloquent and thoughtful interview with Laura Thompson on Sunday, John said how hard it was to look someone in the eye and tell them they ought to buy a yearling. He should try looking, as I have down the years, at a TV camera for a race like the Arc de Triomphe and tell a worldwide TV audience that what they are about to see is the equivalent of the European 1500 metre final, the showdown between the generations to find the best athlete on the continent. When  it’s not. In the European Final the 18 year olds don’t get ten yards start.

The weight for age scale in these championship races is a sacred cow that has needed slaughtering for years.   In 1977 I wrote in the Sunday Times of the inequity of the four year old Orange Bay having to concede 10lb to the Derby winner The Minstrel who beat him a short head and was then hustled off to stud as the “conqueror” of the older horses. The late John Hislop, owner of Brigadier Gerard and one of the great gurus of thoroughbred breeding, told me the weight for age scale was essential for “the good of the breed.” I think that was wrong then and even more wrong now.

Among Hislop’s reasons was that if you ran these championship races at level weights very few three year olds would take part. So what? My point has always been that to relate to a wider audience, a “championship” must mean what it says on the tin. If a three year old wants to take the kudos of beating the older horses, let him do so at level weights. If he doesn’t want to risk it until he is a four year old, that’s fine. But he can’t retire claiming to be the best around.

Last Saturday we hailed a brilliant new star as St Nicholas Abbey dazzled in victory at Doncaster. This Thursday we run a 24 page tribute to Sea The Stars whose unprecedented career is over just as the public begin to realise his greatness. If flat racing really wants to hold its place on the sports pages – and  there were a mere three paragraphs in last week’s Sunday Times  – it would be planning  a showdown with the new hero tilting at the current one just as Denman so memorably did with  Kauto Star at Cheltenham. But it will never happen. It ought to.
This is in no way to decry Sea The Stars who I believe to be the finest three year old I have ever seen, and that’s including Ribot, Sea Bird, and Nijinsky. At level weights he would still have won The Eclipse, The Juddmonte and The Irish Champion. And whilst his verdict of only 2 lengths over the 8lb conceding Youmzain in the Arc makes that horse mathematically superior, most people who watched the race would agree that Sea The Stars had power enough to succeed at parity. But Sea The Stars is off to stud. He has apparently – in the flat racing argot which people like John Gosden and me perpetuate – “nothing left to prove.” Oh yes he has. It is – could he beat St Nicholas Abbey at level weights?
That we can never know, and in the almost inconceivably unlikely event of St Nicholas Abbey equalling Sea The Stars’ three year old performance next season, he would be retired too.  I would not then blame the Coolmore team any more than I find any fault with the Tsui family. After what their so cherished home-bred has done both for them and for us this summer why should they risk him for another season when a multi-million stud career is guaranteed, and if he did run against the new upstart the dice would be loaded against him? For them it is, in the current phrase, a “no-brainer.”

But it’s a terrible situation for flat racing as a “sport”.  Have as many wacky ideas as you like to attract a new audience, racee over three furlongs or start at 10am on Saturday morning in fancy dress if you want to, but first make sure that the true championship showdowns are run under conditions an interested outsider can understand. At the moment they can’t. If the answers I get are the same as they were 34 years ago, I shall have to conclude that all these worthy committees on “Racing for Change” don’t really see this as a sport at all.
To take the line from the song – “Tell me it ain’t so.”

More Posts


Sunday Times 2nd June. He is no wooden horse. City Of Troy had looked like a hollow thing in the 2,000 Guineas but but restored

2,000 GUINEAS 2024

SUNDAY TIMES 5TH May 2024 Pegasus lost his wings. Dreams of City Of Troy soaring to the ultimate racing heights didn’t last a minute. 50


Sunday Times 5th May 2023 Utterly unprecedented. Not only did Willie Mullins become the first Irish trainer in 70 years to land the UK trainer’s